How Numeric Optimization Makes Us Stupid - And What to Do?
“Breathing is dangerous — therefore, let’s seal the nose and inject oxygen directly into our blood!”
This is almost what two small Baltic nations — Lithuania and Latvia — are doing by planning to spend over €1 billion to capture CO₂ from factories, liquefy it and ship it to the North Sea for underground storage — while cutting their own forests that naturally regulate climate.
Why? Because we have defined CO₂ as a number to be reduced — even though the atmosphere contains much more water vapor, which is itself a major greenhouse gas. Yet we reduce the complexity of climate to CO₂ accounting and build billion-euro infrastructure around it!
Meanwhile, these countries continue cutting forests — living systems that regulate atmospheric water, rainfall, local climate and entire ecosystems:
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s40663-018-0138-y
Lithuania's mature forests cover only about 7% of its territory, although official statistics advertise 33.9% “forest cover” — a category that also includes clear-cut and other treeless forest land.
This is the fundamental flaw of narrow arithmometric thinking: by optimizing one number, it inevitably becomes blind to the larger system.
The same madness happens everywhere whenever we start chasing KPIs — the core foundation of modern “business thinking”...
How do we fix this madness?
My approach is Structured Dialectics, which extends the problem into an analysis of our cognition. Here is a short 5-minute presentation:
https://dialexity.com/blog/presentation-at-ilia-state-university/
Yet this is still a theory rather than a “quick practical solution”...
So what could we do practically to move away from arithmometric madness?