The Intersection of Decision Management and Knowledge Management

For years, I harbored a belief that Decision Management and Knowledge Management (KM) were two sides of the same coin. Decision Management, with its focus on documenting, managing, simulating, and automating decisions, seemed like a natural partner to Knowledge Management, which is dedicated to creating a searchable repository for enterprise knowledge. I envisioned these two disciplines as a Venn diagram, with overlapping applications that could streamline and enhance organizational efficiency. However, my understanding of Knowledge Management was, as it turned out, somewhat misguided.

A New Perspective on Knowledge Management

Recently, I had the opportunity to interview several KM implementation experts, which opened my eyes to the realities of how Knowledge Management is actually implemented and the reasons behind these practices. The gap between what is possible and what is actually implemented in KM is vast. This realization sparked an idea: perhaps there is a niche for a new KM product feature or capability that could address these gaps. If you’re considering starting a company, this could be an exciting opportunity to innovate in the KM space.

As I delve into my own ultimate vision for Decision Intelligence, which is still in the works and yet to be published, I see a clear need for an automated repository. This repository would document, archive, and track the rationale behind business decisions, as well as any changes and updates made to them. I initially assumed that this was the role of Knowledge Management. While some KM offerings may indeed possess these capabilities, they are not what customers are currently purchasing and implementing. Instead, Knowledge Management has evolved into what is now commonly referred to as AI-enabled chat—a tool for automating product documentation and best practices inquiries.

This revelation left me feeling somewhat disheartened by the apparent short-sightedness of this trend. What we truly need is an automated archival capability that connects decision owners, change management, and change capture, along with simulation outputs, to create a comprehensive narrative around decision changes, expectations, and outcomes.

The CRM Challenge

In articulating this need, I was immediately confronted with what I have come to call “the CRM challenge.” Anyone who has implemented or managed a customer relationship management (CRM) solution understands this concept all too well. A CRM is only as effective as the salespeople who update and manage sales records. Similarly, agencies face challenges in getting billable resources to update time cards. When you expect people to provide a narrative, rationale, or context for their activities, what often begins as a sincere effort can quickly result in significant gaps. It’s akin to New Year’s resolutions for enterprise systems—we all start with the best intentions, but by the end of the first month or quarter, we find ourselves facing a series of broken promises. The gap in tracking and intelligence only widens as the year progresses.

Imagining an Ideal Future

In an ideal world, whenever a change is made to any system or process, an artificial intelligence (AI) should prompt you to film a brief video chat explaining why the change was necessary, what business outcomes necessitated it, what metrics were used to measure its success, and whether it was successfully implemented in operational processes. Imagine the potential of such a system in a fast-moving organization:

A tech company, known for its innovative solutions, plans to raise the price of its flagship software. As the pricing strategy team gears up to execute this adjustment, an AI system alerts them on their dashboard, recommending they analyze the outcomes of the last two instances when they contemplated a similar price hike. The AI presents video footage showing that increasing the price could negatively impact customer retention and market share.

By linking past actions with future considerations, a company can create a valuable connection between its constitution, morals, and history, and its future actions. This enables organizations to learn from their successes and, perhaps most importantly, helps them avoid repeating past mistakes.

The Role of Decision Intelligence

Decision Intelligence represents a significant advancement in documenting, managing, and simulating the reasons and methods behind business decisions. However, if it is not connected to how these decisions were made in the past, it misses a powerful and necessary link to growth. By integrating Decision Intelligence with a robust archival system, organizations can gain deeper insights into their decision-making processes and make more informed choices moving forward.

While Knowledge Management and Decision Management may not be the identical twins I once believed them to be, they are undoubtedly complementary disciplines. By understanding the current landscape of KM and envisioning a future where Decision Intelligence plays a central role, organizations can unlock new levels of efficiency, growth, and innovation. The journey to achieving this vision may be challenging, but the potential rewards are well worth the effort.