Creating Measurable Outcomes for AI Investments

Forrester’s 2026 Technology & AI Predictions highlight a significant shift in how enterprises approach AI investments. As leadership teams increasingly prioritize measurable business outcomes, there is a growing trend towards selectivity in AI spending. The firm anticipates that 25% of planned AI expenditures will be deferred to 2027, reflecting a cautious approach among organizations. Alarmingly, only 15% of AI decision-makers reported EBITDA improvements in the past year, underscoring the need for strategic alignment and clear success metrics. Organizations that meticulously define success metrics before deployment are better positioned to withstand the scrutiny of investment decisions. (Reference)

This advice isn’t risky. As a matter of fact, to anyone whom has ever had IT or Line of Business responsibilities this is advice they undoubtedly received in school before pursuing their chosen field. 

Anyway you cut it, isn’t understanding the problem statement, what a reasonable solution looks like, and how you’re going to measure the outcomes to determine success, the way to approach any issue (technological or otherwise)?

At its core, understanding the problem statement, envisioning a reasonable solution, and establishing metrics to measure success are essential steps in addressing any issue, whether technological or otherwise. This approach is echoed by experts across various decision-making domains—strategic, operational, and tactical. Some experts integrate this requirement into the discovery process, questioning what decisions need to be made, who owns them, and how they will be measured. Others use it as a starting point to articulate any decision process. Clearly defining why, how, and what success looks like is fundamental to achieving it.

So, why should AI solution implementation be any different? Is this merely a reflection of the AI hype cycle? Perhaps. However, every significant enterprise project should begin with articulating goals and success metrics, regardless of the technology involved.

The Critical Steps to Creating Measurable Outcomes

Here’s what you should think about:

1. Start with the Business Objective: Before defining a single metric, ask:

  • What business problem are we solving?

  • What strategic initiative does this support?

  • What decision justified funding this project?

  • What measurable outcome would make executives say this was a success?

2. Identify Stakeholders and Their Success Criteria: Consider carefully that different stakeholders define success differently. Engaging with stakeholders early in the process ensures that their perspectives are incorporated, leading to a more comprehensive and aligned project.

3. Build a Success Hierarchy: Think in layers: strategic outcomes to business outcomes to operational to project. (For example, revenue or profitability to productivity or compliance to error reduction or faster approval processes to features delivered or training delivered.) This hierarchical approach ensures that all levels of the organization are aligned with the project’s objectives.

4. Develop Leading and Lagging Indicators: Leading indicators predict future success, while lagging indicators confirm success in retrospect. By balancing both types of indicators, organizations can maintain a proactive stance and make informed adjustments as needed.

5. Create SMART Metrics: Every metric should be:

  • Specific

  • Measurable

  • Achievable

  • Relevant

  • Time-bound

SMART metrics provide clarity and focus, ensuring that efforts are directed towards meaningful objectives.

6. Establish Baselines: You cannot demonstrate improvement without knowing where you started. Establishing baselines allows organizations to track progress and demonstrate the impact of their initiatives.

7. Define Measurement Ownership: Every metric should have an executive owner, a business owner, an agreed-upon data source and reporting frequency, and accountability. If no one owns a metric, it usually won’t drive action. Clear ownership ensures that metrics are monitored and that insights are acted upon.

8. Measure Benefits Realization: Many organizations stop measuring once the project goes live. Keep in mind, benefits often take time to materialize. Continuous measurement allows organizations to capture long-term value and make necessary adjustments.

9. Build a Success Dashboard: Lastly, for Decision Intelligence, in particular, I’d recommend adding an additional dimension focused on Decision Outcomes. For projects involving analytics, AI, or decision automation, measure not only whether the system was delivered, but whether it improves the quality, speed, consistency, transparency, and business impact of decisions. Metrics such as decision cycle time, recommendation acceptance rate, policy compliance, decision accuracy, override frequency, and financial impact per decision can provide a more meaningful assessment of value than traditional IT metrics alone. This aligns project success with the measurable business outcomes that decision intelligence initiatives are ultimately intended to achieve.

Articulate Points of Potential Failure

Lastly, consider where your project will fail. This consideration should not only be in the project itself, but also in how you track its progress, milestones, and overall project success. Failure can come in many forms:

  • Measuring activity instead of outcomes

  • Tracking too many KPIs

  • Ignoring qualitative feedback

  • Failing to establish baselines

  • Not assigning metric ownership

  • Ending measurement at project completion

  • Measuring only IT performance rather than business value

This outline was generated from decades of project success and failure and, while this experience comes from a pre-AI era, it still works perfectly in an AI world. By adhering to these principles, organizations can navigate the complexities of AI implementation and achieve sustainable business outcomes.